Common WBS Elements
In addition to including product-oriented elements, every WBS includes program management as a level 2 element, as well as other common elements like integration and assembly, government furnished equipment, and government testing. Table 6 lists and describes common elements that that support a program. For example, systems engineering, program management, integration, and testing are necessary support functions for developing, testing, producing, and fielding hardware or software elements.
Table 6: Common Elements in Work Breakdown Structures
Common element | Description |
---|---|
Integration, assembly, test, and checkout | All effort of technical and functional activities associated with the design, development, and production of mating surfaces, structures, equipment, parts, materials, and software required to assemble level 3 equipment (hardware and software) elements into level 2 mission equipment (hardware and software) |
System engineering | The technical and management efforts of directing and controlling a totally integrated engineering effort of a system or program |
Program management | The business and administrative planning, organizing, directing, coordinating, controlling, and approval actions designated to accomplish overall program objectives not associated with specific hardware elements and not included in systems engineering |
Training | Deliverable training services, devices, accessories, aids, equipment, and parts used to facilitate instruction in which personnel will learn to operate and maintain the system with maximum efficiency |
Data | The deliverable data that must be on a contract data requirements list, including technical publications, engineering data, support data, and management data needed to configure management, cost, schedule, contractual data management, and program management |
System test and evaluation | The use of prototype, production, or specifically fabricated hardware and software to obtain or validate engineering data on the performance of the system under development; also includes all effort associated with design and production of models, specimens, fixtures, and instrumentation in support of the system-level test program |
Peculiar support equipment | Equipment uniquely needed to support the program: vehicles, equipment, tools, and the like to fuel, service, transport, hoist, repair, overhaul, assemble and disassemble, test, inspect, or otherwise maintain mission equipment, as well as equipment or software required to maintain or modify the software portions of the system |
Common support equipment | Equipment not unique to the program and available in inventory for use by many programs |
Operational and site activation | Installation of mission and support equipment in the operations or support facilities and complete system checkout or shakedown to ensure operational status; may include real estate, construction, conversion, utilities, and equipment to provide all facilities needed to house, service, and launch prime mission equipment |
Facilities | Includes construction, conversion, or expansion of existing industrial facilities for production, inventory, and contractor depot maintenance required as a result of the specific system |
Initial spares and repair parts | Includes the deliverable spare components, assemblies, and subassemblies used for initial replacement purposes in the materiel system equipment end item |
Source: DOD | GAO-20-195G
Therefore, in addition to having a product-oriented WBS for the prime mission equipment that breaks down the physical pieces of, for example, an aircraft, information technology system, or satellite, the WBS should include these common elements to ensure that all effort is identified at the outset. This, in turn, will facilitate planning and managing the overall effort, because the WBS should be the starting point for developing the detailed schedule. Figure 8 shows a program WBS, including common elements, for a sea system.
Figure 8: A Work Breakdown Structure with Common Elements
-
Sea System
-
Ship
- Hull structure
- Propulsion plant
- Electric plant
- Command, comm. and surveillance
- Fire control
- Auxiliary systems
- …
-
Ship
- System engineering
- Program management
- System test and evaluation
- Training
- Program management
- Peculiar support equipment
- Common support equipment
- Operational/site activation
The WBS in figure 8 encompasses the whole program. The contractor may also develop a contract WBS that extends the lower-level components to reflect its responsibilities. See figure 9.
Figure 9: A Contract Work Breakdown Structure
Left panel:
-
Sea System
-
Ship
- Hull structure
- Propulsion plant
- Electric plant
-
Command, comm. and surveillance
- Fire control
- Auxiliary systems
- Outfit and furnishings
- Armament
- Total ship integration/engineering
- Ship assembly and support services
- System engineering
- Program management
- System test and evaluation
-
Ship
Right Panel:
-
Fire control
-
Radar
- Receiver
- Transmitter
- Antenna
-
Radar applications S/W (to CSCI level)
-
Build 1
- CSCI 1…n
- CSC1 to CSCI integration and checkout
-
Build 2…n
- CSCI 1…n
- CSC1 to CSCI integration and checkout
- Radar applications S/W integration, assembly, test, and checkout
-
Build 1
- Radar system S/W
-
Radar
Figure 9 shows how a prime contractor may require its subcontractor to use the WBS to report work progress. In this example, the fire control effort (a level 4 element in the prime contractor’s WBS) is the first level for the subcontractor. Thus, all fire control expenditures at level 1 of the subcontractor’s contract WBS would map to the fire control element at level 4 in the program WBS. This shows how a subcontractor would break a level 4 item down to lower levels to accomplish the work, which when rolled up to the prime WBS, would show effort at levels 4-8.